Register for AME 2026

July 29-30 in Grand Rapids, MI 

Automation Alley Trade Missions

Your Gateway to New, High-Growth Markets.

Join Project DIAMOnD Academy

Register for the Integr8 2026 Series

The Problem with Blaming Robots for Taking Our Jobs

by | Jun 20, 2022

Summary

For decades, the effects of automation have been fiercely debated. Are we missing the bigger picture? Jane Hu writes in The Economist that "the rise and fall of automation discourse is a richer subject than automation itself. The debate becomes a kind of historical index—a sign of the times, even if it doesn’t always accurately describe the times."

In the late nineteen-forties, Delmar Harder, a vice-president at Ford, popularized the term “automation”—a “nickname,” he said, for the increased mechanization at the company’s Detroit factory. Harder was mostly talking about the automatic transfer of car parts between machines, but the concept soon grew legs—and sometimes a robotic arm—to encompass a range of practices and possibilities.

From the immediate postwar years to the late nineteen-sixties, America underwent what we might call an automation boom, not only in the automotive sector but in most heavy-manufacturing industries. As new technology made factory work more efficient, it also rendered factory workers redundant, often displacing them into a growing service sector. Automation looks a little different these days, but the rhetoric around it remains basically the same. Popular discourse alternates between a vision of benevolent machines—ones that could, say, carry out dangerous or gruelling tasks—and one of job-stealing robots. Such talk frequently swells in moments of technological innovation. (Think of the birth of the personal computer, or, more recently, of the rise of Amazon.) covid-19 only intensified this anxiety, as labor shortages, and the pressure to keep people safe, gave companies new opportunities to automate. Are robots really, finally, going to replace us?

Read full artice

The New Yorker

Guardian Media Group is a global news organisation that delivers fearless, investigative journalism giving a voice to the powerless and holding power to account.Our independent ownership structure means we are entirely free from political and commercial influence. Only our values determine the stories we choose to cover – relentlessly and courageously.‍

More

Forging the Workforce of the AI Age

There is no meaningful discussion about the future of the workforce without addressing artificial intelligence. This transformative technology, capable of driving profound gains in productivity and insight, has reached every corner of the global economy and is...

Related

Forging the Workforce of the AI Age

Forging the Workforce of the AI Age

From the generational transfer of knowledge to the balance between technical and human-centered skills, from successful AI implementation to lessons learned through failure, this playbook reflects a broad spectrum of perspectives. It is a curated collection of insights from Automation Alley’s network of industry, academia and government partners, all working toward a more resilient, competitive and future-ready workforce in the United States.